Thursday, August 11, 2022

When Does Carpal Tunnel Require Surgery

Don't Miss

How Effective Is Surgery

What You Need to Do Before Having Carpal Tunnel Surgery

Surgery is usually only considered if symptoms return regularly and problems associated with the painful sensations increase despite trying other treatments such as splints or corticosteroid injections. In those cases surgery can provide better relief than repeat injections or splint treatments.

Acute carpal tunnel syndrome with sudden and severe pain is quite rare. It most often occurs after an injury, infection or bleeding in the wrist. Having surgery quickly is then often the only way to get effective relief.

Most peoples symptoms disappear after surgery: If you don’t experience any lasting abnormal sensations or loss of strength in the wrist, the symptoms usually improve rapidly. One of the things that determines how fast you recover is how badly the nerve was damaged. It can take several weeks or months for more severe symptoms to go away completely. The pain usually improves pretty fast, but the abnormal sensations may need more time to disappear. So it might be preferable to not wait too long to have surgery.

If the surgical procedure doesn’t have the desired outcome, there are a number of possible explanations:

  • The condition might already be at such an advanced stage that surgery can no longer make the symptoms go away completely.
  • The may have been wrong, so surgery was performed even though the symptoms were being caused by something else.
  • Symptoms may persist or worsen if there is a surgical error or the flexor retinaculum is not cut through completely.

What Happens If It Is Left Untreated

If left untreated, carpal tunnel syndrome could lead to weakness, lack of coordination, and permanent nerve damage. When carpal tunnel syndrome begins to disrupt your routine, make an appointment with an orthopedic doctor. Taking action soon could mean avoiding nerve damage. A lot of people with carpal tunnel syndrome tend to wait until theyve completely gone numb in the hand. This could lead to irreversible nerve damage. Whether you need conservative treatment or surgery, carpal tunnel syndrome can be successfully treated. Carpal tunnel release surgery has an over 95 percent success rate, provided its not done too late.

Should Older Adults Have Carpal Tunnel Release Surgery

Older adults seem to have a greater chance of developing carpal tunnel syndrome and with more severe symptoms. There is plenty of research evidence to support the benefits of surgery to release the soft tissues around the affected nerve in the general adult population. But no one has really studied the results of surgical release in the older adult group.

This study looked at the surgical results for 78 adults who had carpal tunnel surgery. Each individual was carefully evaluated before surgery to make sure the diagnosis was correct. The most reliable test for carpal tunnel syndrome is a nerve conduction study. Only patients whose carpal tunnel syndrome was confirmed with nerve conduction studies were included. The surgery done was an endoscopic carpal tunnel release.

Patient charts were reviewed, data collected, and statistics analyzed. The kinds of information viewed included demographic data , clinical presentation , and patient satisfaction . Each patient filled out several surveys answering questions about pain, numbness, sleep, and daily function.

Those patients who did report pain before surgery were able to get relief from their pain following the carpal tunnel release procedure. Almost everyone who had numbness before surgery was no longer bothered by this symptom.

Don’t Miss: Where Is Your Carpal Tunnel

Carpal Tunnel Syndrome: When Is Surgery Considered Or Needed

Most people with carpal tunnel syndrome only consider having surgery if other treatments don’t provide enough relief. Surgery can help relieve symptoms or make them go away for good, but it is not without risks.

In carpal tunnel syndrome the median nerve, which runs through the carpal tunnel in your wrist, is squashed. This can cause pain, tingling and numbness, and affect certain hand movements. Surgical treatment involves cutting a fibrous band on the inside of the wrist, known as the flexor retinaculum. The aim is to reduce pressure on the median nerve. This is one of the most commonly performed surgical procedures in Germany.

Although surgery sometimes makes the symptoms go away for good, it’s not always necessary. Other treatments are usually preferred, especially if the condition is still in an early stage. Urgent surgery is usually only needed for treating a very uncommon condition called acute carpal tunnel syndrome.

There are two possible surgical procedures:

  • Open carpal tunnel release: The surgeon makes a cut on the inside of the wrist, and then cuts right through the flexor retinaculum.
  • Endoscopic carpal tunnel release: Here the surgeon has to make a cut on your palm and your wrist. They insert a very small camera through one of the cuts to monitor the procedure, and guide an instrument through the second cut to then cut right through the flexor retinaculum. Another endoscopic technique involves using just one small cut in the wrist.

What Happens During Surgery

Why Carpal Tunnel Is Worse Than You Think

Surgery can be performed either as an open or endoscopic technique. Both are performed as outpatient surgery, require small incisions, and take only 10 minutes. Both procedures involve cutting the carpal ligament to relieve pressure on the median nerve. Recovery varies, depending on the incision size and the patients overall health.

Recommended Reading: Does Carpal Tunnel Surgery Work

Drug Treatment And Surgery

In addition to wearing splints and other comfort measures, prescription medications or injections are available.

Oral corticosteroid medication may decrease inflammation and swelling, which might help to reduce pressure on the median nerve. Corticosteroid medication is also available as an injection into the wrist. Injections seem to be more effective than oral corticosteroids for CTS.

No significant evidence supports the use of non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs to treat CTS.

Conventional treatments for CTS should take place under the guidance of a doctor.

If CTS relates to an underlying condition, such as diabetes, arthritis, or hypothyroidism, try to control the condition and symptoms should reduce.

For people who develop CTS during pregnancy, symptoms usually resolve 6 to 12 weeks after giving birth. Some specialists recommend putting a splint on the wrist while sleeping.

Sometimes, if severe compression is occurring on the median nerve, it may be causing nerve damage or muscle wasting that requires further treatment.

The treating doctor may recommend surgery if CTS is severe and if non-surgical treatments do not help. Surgical treatment of CTS does appear to have the best outcome. Studies have shown that 6 to 12 months after surgery, CTS improves more than it would with just a splint or some other non-surgical treatment.

The two types of surgery available for CTS are:

It Is Secure And Successful To Use Both The Conventional Open Approach And The Less Invasive Approach

There were some worries that the procedure was risky and more susceptible to complications when endoscopic methods to carpal tunnel surgery were new. But current studies show that both methods are equally safe and accurate. In addition, a faster recovery period and return-to-work date can be given by the endoscopic approach. Your surgeon’s level of familiarity with your chosen approach of carpal tunnel treatment options would need the highest attention.

Read Also: Does Carpal Tunnel Get Worse At Night

What Is The Carpal Tunnel

The carpal tunnel is a narrow canal or tube in the wrist. Similarly to a tunnel you could travel through by car, this part of the wrist allows the median nerve and tendons to connect the hand and forearm. The parts of this tunnel include:

  • Carpal bones: These bones make up the bottom and sides of the tunnel. They are formed in a semi-circle.
  • Ligament: The top of the tunnel, the ligament is a strong tissue that holds the tunnel together.

Inside the tunnel are the median nerve and tendons.

  • Median nerve: This nerve provides feeling to most of the fingers in the hand . It also adds strength to the base of the thumb and index finger.
  • Tendons: Rope-like structures, tendons connect muscles in the forearm to the bones in the hand. They allow the fingers and thumb to bend.

What Can You Do Other Than Have Surgery

Do you need surgery for carpal tunnel syndrome?

You can try several home treatments to help relieve your symptoms. This may be all you need to do for mild symptoms of carpal tunnel syndrome. Doctors suggest that you try these treatments for 3 to 12 months before you think about having surgery. It often helps to try several treatments at the same time.

You may try to:

  • Rest your hand for 1 or 2 weeks. Stop activities that hurt.
  • Put ice on the palm of your hand and wrist for 10 to 15 minutes at a time.
  • Take nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs , such as naproxen or ibuprofen. Studies haven’t shown NSAIDs to be effective for carpal tunnel syndrome, but they may help relieve your symptoms. Talk to your doctor before taking NSAIDs. They can cause side effects. Be safe with medicines. Read and follow all instructions on the label.
  • Change the way you do certain hand motions.
  • Wear a wrist splint. It’s usually worn at night, but you can wear it during the day.

Other choices

  • You can work with a physical therapist to learn how to do activities in a new way.
  • If these home care treatments don’t help, you may be able to take corticosteroid shots or pills to improve your symptoms.
  • You can try yoga.
  • Symptoms of carpal tunnel syndrome in pregnant women often go away after childbirth. Unless your symptoms are very bad, you may want to put off having surgery and see if your symptoms go away after you have the baby.

Rest, ice, and other home treatments may be all you need if you’ve had mild symptoms for a short time.

You May Like: Can Invisalign Cause Shoulder Pain

What Happens After Carpal Tunnel Surgery

Your wrist will likely be in a heavy bandage or a splint for 1 to 2 weeks. Doctors usually schedule another appointment to remove the bandage or splint. During this time, you may be encouraged to move your fingers to help prevent stiffness.

You’ll probably have pain in your hand and wrist after surgery. It’s usually controlled with pain medicines taken by mouth. The surgeon may also have you keep the affected hand elevated while sleeping at night to help decrease swelling.

Once the splint is removed, you will likely begin a physical therapy program. The physical therapist will teach you motion exercises to improve the movement of your wrist and hand. These exercises will speed healing and strengthen the area. You may still need to sometimes use a splint or brace for a month or so after surgery.

The recovery period can take anywhere from a few days to a few months. In the meantime, you may need to adjust job duties or even take time off from work while you heal. Your doctor will talk to you about activity restrictions you should follow after surgery.

Let your doctor know about any of the following:

  • Fever
  • Redness, swelling, bleeding, or other drainage from the incision
  • Increased pain around the incision

These problems may need to be treated. Talk to your doctor about what you should expect and what problems mean you need to see your doctor right away.

Carpal Tunnel Release Surgery In Watertown Ny

Carpal tunnel release surgery to widen the space in the carpal tunnel is a relatively quick procedure and takes under an hour to complete. It also requires a fairly short recovery period before you begin to experience improvement in your symptoms and regain function in your hand.

The medical team here at North Country Orthopaedic Group regularly performs carpal tunnel release surgery in our ambulatory surgical center in Watertown. We can help you experience relief from your symptoms and prevent future disability, so you can continue doing the things you love and living a normal lifestyle.

To request a consultation with one of our orthopedists, call North Country Orthopaedic Group today at 782-1650 or fill out our appointment request form online now. We look forward to helping you recover the full use of your hands once again.

Recommended Reading: Can Eating Gluten Cause Stomach Pain

Questions To Ask Your Doctor

  • How do you know that carpal tunnel syndrome is causing my symptoms?
  • What can I do to relieve my pain?
  • Are there any special exercises I can do to strengthen my hand and wrist?
  • What is the best treatment option? Will I need surgery?
  • How long will it take to recover?
  • Is it likely that Ill experience this problem again, either in this hand/arm or in my other hand/arm?

You May Like: Do Muscle Relaxers Help Sciatic Nerve Pain

Mayo Clinic Q And A: Recovery After Surgery For Carpal Tunnel Syndrome Whats Normal And Whats Not

Carpal Tunnel Syndrome Treatment Florida

DEAR MAYO CLINIC: Three months ago, I had surgery on my left wrist to treat carpal tunnel syndrome. Since then, I am in much more pain than before surgery, and two of my fingers are completely numb. I cannot even button a button, and tying my shoes is a chore. What would cause the pain to worsen after surgery? Could another surgery remedy the problem, or is this my new normal?

ANSWER: Your condition as it stands now shouldnt be considered a new normal. Its possible your symptoms are part of the recovery from surgery, and they may improve with time. It would be a good idea, however, to meet with your surgeon now, so he or she can reassess your condition and decide if you need additional tests or treatment.

Carpal tunnel syndrome is caused by compression of the median nerve within the carpal tunnel a narrow passageway on the palm side of your wrist. The median nerve runs from your forearm through the carpal tunnel and into your hand. It controls the sensations you feel on the palm side of your thumb and fingers, except the little finger. Carpal tunnel syndrome often causes numbness and tingling in the hand and arm. Surgery to treat it involves relieving pressure on the median nerve by cutting the ligament that crosses over it.

Its helpful to note, too, that nerves typically improve after surgery at a rate of about 1 inch per month. When sensation returns, it happens gradually. In general, full recovery after carpal tunnel syndrome may take up to a year.

Read Also: Can You Have Carpal Tunnel In Your Feet

Active Hands For Life It Is A Wonderful Concept

I had a lot of hand pain that was waking me up throughout the night due to Carpal Tunnel Syndrome. I purchased the Carpal Solution, followed the directions and after the fourth night my pain was completely eliminated.

Since I use the computer daily as part of my job, I am going to purchase some additional Carpal Solution Therapy Pacs to have on hand when symptoms flare up. It is great to have a reliable therapy available, which I can depend upon.

Patti Mortgage Broker Texas.

Fantastic product! I now have feeling in my thumb and forefinger . I had been told by several doctors over the years that my only recourse was to have an operation which I would not give in to.

No doubt, I made the correct decision over the years. I am telling everyone I know and come in contact with about the Carpal Solution. 

Billy, 3M Factory Worker. Wisconsin

Fourteen nights in a row with sound sleep. It required a little more time with my left hand, but over a three week period both hands were feeling better. I am so pleased with this product.

I wore the Carpal Solution for fourteen nights. My left hand is now fine, it is remarkable, but my right hand may still require surgery, I will keep doing the six week protocol and then make a decision

Linda, Cashier Indianapolis, Indiana

How Often Is Hand Pain Caused By Carpal Tunnel Syndrome

While carpal tunnel syndrome is a common condition, it has a different set of symptoms from many other sources of hand pain. There are actually several similar conditions that cause hand pain. These include:

  • De Quervains tendinosis: A condition where swelling affects the wrist and base of the thumb. In this condition, you will feel pain when you make a fist and simulate shaking someones hand.
  • Trigger finger: This condition causes soreness at the base of the finger or thumb. Trigger finger also causes pain, locking and stiffness when bending the fingers and thumb.
  • Arthritis: This is a general term for many conditions that cause stiffness and swelling in your joints. Arthritis can impact many joints in your body and ranges from causing small amounts of discomfort to breaking down the joint over time .

Also Check: What Is The Best Treatment For Stomach Pain

When Should Carpal Tunnel Surgery Be Considered

In a nutshell, carpal tunnel surgery is recommended:

  • When wrist splints, corticosteroid, physical therapy or even stem cell treatments dont work, surgery will be recommended.
  • If the patient still suffers from symptoms after several weeks and months of trying all the available nonsurgical treatment options, surgery will usually be the only alternative.
  • When the pain is hampering the patients daily activities, or there is persistent loss of feeling or coordination in the fingers or hand.
  • Nerve tests clearly indicate damage to the median nerve, surgical remedy would be the obvious solution for treatment as well as for preventing permanent nerve damage. Ultrasound is an alternative that improves moderate to severe carpal tunnel.

Research has demonstrated that results after surgery are better if treated earlier than later. For example, the fingers could weaken until they become unusable. Which is why patients with carpal tunnel are encouraged to seek treatment before their symptoms become debilitating.

You Do Not Need As Much Time Off Work As You’re Thinking About

What to expect: Carpal tunnel surgery in the clinic

Some individuals delay or prevent carpal tunnel treatment surgery to release the carpal tunnel because they are concerned that the healing process will take them away from work for too long. But unless repetitive manual labor is involved in your career, you can be able to return to work in a week or two. Before returning to work, those who perform manual labor can need to wait around 6 to 8 weeks.

Also Check: Where Is The Pain From Carpal Tunnel

What Is The Success Rate For Carpal Tunnel Syndrome Surgery

Surgery for carpal tunnel syndrome has a very high success rate of over 90%. Many symptoms are relieved quickly after treatment, including tingling sensation in the hands and waking up at night. Numbness may take longer to be relieved, even up to three months. Surgery wont help if carpal tunnel syndrome is the wrong diagnosis.

When the carpal tunnel syndrome has become severe, relief may not be complete. There may be some pain in the palm around the incisions that can last up to a few months. Other after-surgery pain may not be related to carpal tunnel syndrome. Patients who complain of pain or whose symptoms remain unchanged after surgery either had severe carpal tunnel syndrome, had a nerve that was not completely released during surgery, or did not really have carpal tunnel syndrome. Only a small percentage of patients do not gain substantial relief from symptoms.

Last reviewed by a Cleveland Clinic medical professional on 10/22/2019.


Best Home Treatment Methods

Before scheduling a medical procedure you can curb, and sometimes heal, your carpal tunnel through simple at-home remedies. Home treatments should also be used if your cause of carpal tunnel is temporary, such as a side effect of pregnancy.

Because of the potential for long-term nerve damage, its important to treat the condition rather than just symptoms of carpal tunnel. If your pain does not go away after trying different home remedies you need to consider the option of surgery.

Recommended Reading: What Does Arthritis Pain Feel Like In The Knee

Why It Is Done

Open carpal tunnel surgery is considered when:

  • You still have symptoms after a long period of nonsurgical treatment. In general, surgery is not considered until after several weeks to months of nonsurgical treatment. But this assumes that you still have symptoms but there’s no sign of nerve damage. Nerve damage would make surgery more urgent.
  • Severe symptoms restrict normal daily activities.
  • There is damage to the median nerve , or a risk of nerve damage.
  • Tumors or other growths need to be removed.

How Is Carpal Tunnel Syndrome Treated

Carpal Tunnel Release

Carpal tunnel syndrome can be treated in two ways: non-surgically or with surgery. There are pros and cons to both approaches. Typically, non-surgical treatments are used for less severe cases and allow you to continue with daily activities without interruption. Surgical treatments can help in more severe cases and have very positive outcomes.

Non-surgical treatments

Non-surgical treatments are usually tried first. Treatment begins by:

  • Wearing a wrist splint at night.
  • Taking nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs, such as ibuprofen.

Other treatments focus on ways to change your environment to decrease symptoms. This is often seen in the workplace, where you can make modifications to help with carpal tunnel. These changes might include:

  • Raising or lowering your chair.
  • Moving your computer keyboard.
  • Changing your hand/wrist position while doing activities.
  • Using recommended splints, exercises and heat treatments from a hand therapist.

Surgical treatments

Surgery is recommended when carpal tunnel syndrome does not respond to non-surgical treatments or has already become severe. The goal of surgery is to increase the size of the tunnel in order to decrease the pressure on the nerves and tendons that pass through the space. This is done by cutting the ligament that covers the carpal tunnel at the base of the palm. This ligament is called the transverse carpal ligament.

If you have surgery, you can expect to:

Also Check: How To Reduce Stomach Pain During Periods Instantly

What Is Carpal Tunnel Surgery

In almost all situations, carpal tunnel surgery involves cutting the transverse carpal ligament on the palm side of the hand in order to relieve pressure on the median nerve in the wrist.

Carpal tunnel surgery can be performed as an open surgery or minimally invasive endoscopic surgery .

Depending on factors like the complexity of the surgery and surgeon/patient preference, the operation may be performed under local anesthesia, with a regional block, or under general anesthesia.

One of the factors influencing response rates is the choice of surgeries. In recent years, many surgeons have turned to endoscopic carpal tunnel release as an alternative to traditional open surgery, which has been shown to require shorter recovery times and allow people to return to work sooner.

This is not to suggest that endoscopic surgery is “better” than open surgery. In the end, there are pros and cons to each that need to be weighed with your doctor, as detailed in a 2019 review published in Current Review of Musculoskeletal Medicine.

  • Fewer complications per 1,000 surgeries

  • Faster recovery

  • Faster return to work

  • Scars are smaller and tend to be less sensitive or obvious

Generally speaking, open and endoscopic carpal tunnel surgeries have similar response rates. Although the endoscopic approach allows for faster recovery times with less scarring, open surgery is associated with slightly fewer complications and costs less.

When Would Surgery Be Needed

If symptoms persist and are not relieved by medication or exercises then surgery may be an option. Surgery involves either local anaesthetic to numb the wrist area during surgery or general anaesthetic. During the surgery, the surgeon will cut the ligament over the front of the wrist with the aim of relieving pressure on the median nerve.After surgery, in most cases, patients can return home on the same day as the procedure. To help prevent swelling in the fingers the arm is kept raised and can stay on the pillow when resting. Wiggling the fingers and making a fist regularly also helps reduce finger swelling. Most individuals return to work and most daily activities in approximately two weeks.

Read Also: Is Heat Or Ice Good For Nerve Pain

More articles

Popular Articles