Carpal Tunnel Syndrome: When Is Surgery Considered Or Needed
Most people with carpal tunnel syndrome only consider having surgery if other treatments don’t provide enough relief. Surgery can help relieve symptoms or make them go away for good, but it is not without risks.
In carpal tunnel syndrome the median nerve, which runs through the carpal tunnel in your wrist, is squashed. This can cause pain, tingling and numbness, and affect certain hand movements. Surgical treatment involves cutting a fibrous band on the inside of the wrist, known as the flexor retinaculum. The aim is to reduce pressure on the median nerve. This is one of the most commonly performed surgical procedures in Germany.
Although surgery sometimes makes the symptoms go away for good, it’s not always necessary. Other treatments are usually preferred, especially if the condition is still in an early stage. Urgent surgery is usually only needed for treating a very uncommon condition called acute carpal tunnel syndrome.
There are two possible surgical procedures:
- Open carpal tunnel release: The surgeon makes a cut on the inside of the wrist, and then cuts right through the flexor retinaculum.
- Endoscopic carpal tunnel release: Here the surgeon has to make a cut on your palm and your wrist. They insert a very small camera through one of the cuts to monitor the procedure, and guide an instrument through the second cut to then cut right through the flexor retinaculum. Another endoscopic technique involves using just one small cut in the wrist.
Medicare Advantage Plans / Part D
Medicare Advantage plans also provide coverage for carpal tunnel surgery. They cover everything Original Medicare covers as well as some additional benefits. However, exactly what it covers and how much the out-of-pocket costs are will vary depending on the specifics of your plan.
Aside from covering the carpal tunnel surgery itself, Medicare Part B or Part C will also cover the following if it is related to your carpal tunnel surgery:
- Visits to the doctors office
- Physical Therapy
- Wrists or hand braces that you will wear at home that are necessary for recovery
- Medications that are given to you during the carpal tunnel surgery or your appointments
Medicare Part D also provides coverage for medications that you need to take at home after your carpal tunnel surgery. This includes pain medications.
What Happens During Carpal Tunnel Surgery
Carpal tunnel release is usually an outpatient procedure, which means that you can go home the same day as the surgery if all goes well. There are 2 types of carpal tunnel release surgery. The traditional method is the open release, in which the surgeon cuts open the wrist to do the surgery.
The other method is endoscopic carpal tunnel release, in which a thin, flexible tube that contains a camera is put into the wrist through a tiny incision . The camera guides the doctor as the surgery is done with thin tools put into the wrist through another small cut.
In either case, here is the general sequence of events in a carpal tunnel release surgery:
Also Check: Is Stomach Pain A Sign Of Pregnancy
Which Surgery Will You Have
Your doctor will also determine which carpal tunnel surgery you’ll have.That’s because a surgeon specializes in one or the other type. The type of surgery makes a huge difference in your final cost.
There are two main types carpal tunnel surgery:
The endoscopic procedure is more expensive. Thats because it requires special training and specialized instruments. But in the long run, the endoscopic procedure results in less pain, faster recovery, and less rehabilitation time.
Considering this could translate into fewer lost work days and wages. So it might actually be the more cost effective surgical option.
Why It Is Done
Open carpal tunnel surgery is considered when:
- Symptoms are still present after a long period of nonsurgical treatment. In general, surgery is not considered until after several weeks to months of nonsurgical treatment. But this assumes that you are having ongoing symptoms but no sign of nerve damage. Nerve damage would make surgery more urgent.
- Severe symptoms restrict normal daily activities.
- There is damage to the median nerve , or a risk of nerve damage.
- Tumors or other growths need to be removed.
Recommended Reading: How To Heal Sprained Wrist Faster
Recovering After The Surgery
You can usually go home shortly after the procedure. Youll be given a prescription to help you manage any pain.
You should be able to do most light activities, such as driving and self-care tasks, while you recover. Your doctor will tell you when you can return to work or more strenuous activities.
Recovery can take anywhere from 2 months to a full year, depending on how severe your nerve damage was before surgery.
Most people have complete relief of their carpal tunnel syndrome after recovery is complete. Recovery can be slowed by other conditions that affect your joints and tendons. In rare cases, carpal tunnel syndrome can reoccur.
Your doctor will continue to monitor you after surgery to make sure youre making progress.
Hand Surgery And Carpal Tunnel Surgery Cost
Prices can vary for hand surgery. A surgeons cost may be based on his or her experience, the type of procedure used, and the geographic location of the office.
Cost may include:
- Hospital or surgical facility costs
- Medical tests
- Prescriptions for medication
- Surgeons fee
Your health insurance plan will likely cover hand surgery and related complications. Pre-certification is generally required for reimbursement or coverage. Be sure to consult with your insurance company in advance of any surgery.
Your satisfaction involves more than a fee:When choosing a plastic surgeon for hand surgery, remember that the surgeons experience and your comfort with him or her is just as important as the final cost of the surgery. Plastic surgery involves many choices. The first and most important is selecting an AS PS member surgeon you can trust. AS PS member surgeons meet rigorous standards:
- Board certification by the American Board of Plastic Surgery® or in Canada by The Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada®
- Complete at least six years of surgical training following medical school with a minimum of three years of plastic surgery residency training
- Pass comprehensive oral and written exams
- Graduate from an accredited medical school
- Complete continuing medical education, including patient safety each year
- Perform surgery in accredited, state-licensed, or Medicare-certified surgical facilities
For your private consultation call 713-360-6857
Read Also: Joint Pain Causes Diagnosis
Costs: Surgical Center Vs Hospital
It would be impractical here to break down the cost for carpal tunnel surgery for your particular circumstances if you have insurance. But without insurance, those costs are much easier to estimate.
The figures below areaverage national costs. They also average the costs for the two types of surgery .
However, they do not take into account anycomplicationswhich might arise. The costs associated with excessive bleeding, nerve damage, reaction to anesthesia would be impossible to estimate for any particular circumstance.
When Does Carpal Tunnel Surgery Become Necessary
This procedure is the last resort. If a physician diagnoses you with carpal tunnel syndrome, you will receive nonsurgical interventions first. These treatments include pain relievers, therapies, special equipment, or steroid shots.
Unfortunately, these may not work. The pain might become too severe, and the electromyography test results may show that surgery is required. The carpal tunnel syndrome might even get worse to the point that the hands become weak already.
If the symptoms ultimately persist for six months despite the treatments, carpal tunnel surgery becomes necessary. This syndrome can get worse over time.
Don’t Miss: How Do You Tell If Your Wrist Is Broken
Prevention And Treatment Of Carpal Tunnel Syndrome
The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention suggests an effective ergonomics program to prevent and alleviate work-related musculoskeletal disorders such as carpal tunnel by:
- Looking out for warning signs
- Showing management commitment
- Providing training in how to identify work-related MSDs
- Assessing working conditions to determine what might be problematic
- Consulting data, including attendance history and medical records
- Implementing controls to reduce the risks associated with a task
- Emphasizing the importance of prevention
- Minimizing risk factors when creating new processes
Occupational Health and Safety Magazine suggests stretching programs in the workplace as another preventative tool to add to a comprehensive workplace ergonomic program. This type of program would entail task-specific, pre-shift stretching and warm-up exercises. Some organizations note improved employee morale and engagement from incorporating stretching into their employees’ workday.
Another tool to assist employees is to provide CarpalAID, a small patch worn on the palm, as soon as symptoms arise. The FDA Class I medical device is a plastic patch that adheres to the palm with a strip of medical grade 3M glue. It uses no medication and works by creating negative pressure on the median nerve. In some cases, CarpalAID can relieve hand pain symptoms in 30 minutes or less. Its small size also makes it ideal for working unencumbered. Learn more about CarpalAID for corporations here.
How Effective Is Surgery
Surgery is usually only considered if symptoms return regularly and problems associated with the painful sensations increase despite trying other treatments such as splints or corticosteroid injections. In those cases surgery can provide better relief than repeat injections or splint treatments.
Acute carpal tunnel syndrome with sudden and severe pain is quite rare. It most often occurs after an injury, infection or bleeding in the wrist. Having surgery quickly is then often the only way to get effective relief.
Most peoples symptoms disappear after surgery: If you don’t experience any lasting abnormal sensations or loss of strength in the wrist, the symptoms usually improve rapidly. One of the things that determines how fast you recover is how badly the nerve was damaged. It can take several weeks or months for more severe symptoms to go away completely. The pain usually improves pretty fast, but the abnormal sensations may need more time to disappear. So it might be preferable to not wait too long to have surgery.
If the surgical procedure doesn’t have the desired outcome, there are a number of possible explanations:
- The condition might already be at such an advanced stage that surgery can no longer make the symptoms go away completely.
- The may have been wrong, so surgery was performed even though the symptoms were being caused by something else.
- Symptoms may persist or worsen if there is a surgical error or the flexor retinaculum is not cut through completely.
Recommended Reading: Is My Wrist Broken Or Sprained
How Can I Reduce The Recovery Time For My Broken Wrist Safely
As a broken wrist can be a painful and frustrating injury for anyone to live with, it is definitely worth investigating the options for physical therapy to help you heal more quickly. Whether you are interested in distal radius fracture physiotherapy, physical therapy for broken wrist with plate, or simply more information on wrist strengthening exercises after fracture, get in touch with our expert team today. They will be able to help advise you on how you can recover from your broken wrist more quickly in the safest way possible.
You May Like: Pineapple Stomach Pain Remedy
Using This Guidewhat’s Covered
Here youll find answers to many of your questions about surgery for carpal tunnel syndrome. Learn how its done, what it may cost, what your recovery may be like, and more.
To see how the surgery works, view our animation below.
For personal insights, see our patient experience videos in which HCF members talk frankly about their preparation, surgery and recovery.
You May Like: Is It Painful To Cut Your Wrist
Does Medicare Cover Diagnostic Testing Carpal Tunnel Syndrome
Yes, Medicare will cover diagnostic testing for Carpal Tunnel Syndrome. Diagnostic tests help doctors diagnose you with carpal tunnel syndrome.
There are several tests your doctor may conduct:
Talk to your doctor about the options that are the most beneficial for you.
Calculation Of The Incremental Cost
The correct way of comparing two surgical interventions is to determine the added benefit that is gained from the added unit cost. This incremental cost-utility ratio is calculated as follows:
where the numerator represents the marginal difference of the mean cost of each intervention and the denominator represents the marginal mean difference of the effectiveness . The expected costs were calculated by multiplying the total cost of a health state by the probability of that health state occurring. The total expected cost was the sum of the expected cost of the successful surgery plus the sum of the expected cost of all complications. For example, the expected costs for reflex sympathetic dystrophy would be calculated as follows: the estimated cost is multiplied by the probability of the complication occurring to give an expected cost of $12.78.
Cost-effectiveness plane showing the study results and the sensitivity analyses. ECTR Endoscopic carpal tunnel release ICUR Incremental cost-utility ratio RSD Reflex sympathetic dystrophy
Recommended Reading: How To Stop Stomach Pain From Eating Pineapple
How Is Carpal Tunnel Syndrome Diagnosed
Youll need a confirmed diagnosis of carpal tunnel syndrome before surgery. There are a number of ways to test for the condition. These are the three most common:
- Compression Test Your wrist is squeezed to further compress the median nerve. If this causes symptoms to flare up, then you have carpal tunnel syndrome.
- Phalens Test This test, which involves hyperflexing the wrist for about a minute, is also intended to trigger symptoms.
- Tinels Test In this test your doctor will tap on the inside of your wrist above the carpal tunnel. If you feel something like an electric shock, then you have carpal tunnel syndrome.
Sometimes, the above tests arent conclusive enough. In these cases, surgeons may run more advanced tests, including electromyography or electroneurography , both of which read the electroactivity of the median nerve to determine if its actually being compressed.
What Are Common Carpal Tunnel Syndrome Symptoms
Common carpal tunnel symptoms include feelings of numbness, pain and tingling in the fingers and wrists and general feelings of achiness in the hand and arm. Carpal tunnel can have various causes, but is commonly caused by repetitive movement such as using a computer keyboard for long periods of time each day or from playing certain sports.
Also Check: Is Stomach Pain A Sign Of Pregnancy
Talk To An Expert Carpal Tunnel Surgeon In Bergen County
As dedicated hand surgery specialists, price and fees are never our main concern at Cohen/Winters. In our patient-focused NJ practice, were dedicated to helping improve lives and relieve emotional and physical pain through surgery. We see this as our calling, not just a job or a business. We are happy to meet with you, examine you and let you know if we recommend surgery for carpal tunnel in your case.
If we feel youll benefit from carpal tunnel surgery, well explain your options for surgical CTS treatment of your hand. Only at that point would we think of a monetary carpal tunnel surgery cost. Even if CTS surgery is not right for you, you will receive lots of medical information and insight that should prove helpful for you. If you would like to know how hand surgery might help in your specific case, and the carpal tunnel surgery cost, we urge you to contact us at the Bergen County offices of Cohen/Winters Aesthetic & Reconstructive Surgery.
Will Medicare Cover Medications For Carpal Tunnel
The medication cost and coverage depend on the prescription your doctor provides. Lets discuss a few different scenarios.
So, there are over-the-counter options like Ibuprofen that dont have coverage. But Ibuprofen only costs a couple of dollars at the drug store.
Then, other options cost over $200 without insurance, such as the Flector patch. If youre in severe pain, talk to your doctor about a sample while you wait for surgery. Diclofenac comes in gel and pill forms. Some Part D plans offer coverage for this medication. Costs for the policy could be as low as $15 a month and $2 or more for the prescription.
Don’t Miss: How To Lose Belly Fat With Sciatica
What Are The Advantages Of Open Carpal Tunnel Technique
Mr Kenton-Smith generally performs a short scar open carpal tunnel release under local anaesthetic in his rooms. This avoids the need for a general anaesthetic and its subsequent recovery. This is a safer option in those people with significant medical conditions. Open carpal tunnel release is the safest way of performing this surgery.
How Can You Prepare For Carpal Tunnel Surgery
Before the procedure, you should do the following:
- Talk to your surgeon about the medications you have. This way, you can avoid chemicals, drugs, and supplements which increase risks. For example, ibuprofen and aspirin might make blood struggle to clot.
- Stop smoking before the surgery. This vice can affect your recovery after carpal tunnel surgery.
- Ask about the fasting requirements. The surgeon might direct you to refrain from eating for certain hours before the operation.
- Take the required tests. Follow the surgeonâs instructions about the examinations you need to take. These include blood tests and ECG tests.
You May Like: Is Stomach Pain A Sign Of Pregnancy